Reading Petite Anglaise: the book was a very surreal experience after having read Petite Anglaise: the blog. I was charmed by the blog when Petite admitted that her long-time boyfriend didn’t want to marry her. The only thing worse that hearing someone say he or she doesn’t love you back, doesn’t know if you’re the one too, or doesn’t want to marry you as well is retelling that experience. When the words come from your own voice, you suddenly have to think about the words themselves, the thoughts that led to them, their motivations, how his chosen words fit against your chosen words – all with conclusion of admitting your were painfully rejected. It takes very strong person not simply keep that secret.
And yet, even with all that, Petite made me envy her gorgeous life through her blog. She lived in Paris, which offered timely anecdotes and experiences at every turn. Her young daughter spoke in maddeningly hilarious or profound statements. Her boyfriend offered continual insights into French culture. Her office served as her parallel port back to English culture. It seemed almost magical. Cut to my shock when reading Petite Anglaise: the book, where Catherine openly mentions her manipulation of reality in the creation of her posts. Those timely anecdotes occurred over years, but were refashioned as current and glossed into a shiny perfection. Her daughter’s speeches were made to look cuter. The Paris lifestyle was exaggerated here and there to fit the bill. Stories and details were purposefully teased out to shepherd her audience. At first, I felt a little angry. Here’s this life I envied, this life that made my own seem imperfect and bland, and now I’m reading that its details were twisted and fabricated.
I know there’s no logical reason to believe a blog is all non-fiction and complete and utter truth. Bloggers don’t even offer promises of complete non-fiction. And yet… I totally believe what I’m reading is the unadulterated truth. Naively, I don’t consider that maybe bloggers see themselves as entertainers, who refashion stories from their own lives as a separate art for public consumption. As the anger washed away by the third mention of manipulation, I actually started to think it was a good idea. But will I still be tempted to believe that every other blog on my blogroll is completely genuine and true? Yes. Probably.
Tonight my guilty reading pleasure, Jen Lancaster, is giving a reading at a bookstore a block from my office. We’re talking so guilty that I only stealthily read her books at bookstores in half hours increments, because what would their ownership say about me? Full disclosure: I only like to own books that I’ve both liked and make me look intellectual, and I’m only willing to own books that at least make me look well read. Considering I only today, for the first time ever, googled Lancaster to see if she had a website, only coincidentally looked at her Appearances page, and found out about this appearance at all of 4pm, I’m taking this as some sort of sign. Am I meant to have her babies? Could be. I was at that bookstore at lunchtime today, of all things! Well, I suppose I have to buy a book now.
If you don’t count the time I stumbled into a lecture late at Oxford, only find out it was being given by the Ngaire Woods and wanted to scream “OH MY GOD! You’re Ngaire Woods!,” I’ve never really met an author before. And of course if you don’t count all my university professors, who were all published in some subject or other. I just knew I dressed a little preppy this morning for a reason.
Elle